Breaking


Showing posts with label OROP DEFENCE. Show all posts
Showing posts with label OROP DEFENCE. Show all posts

Tuesday, 8 November 2016

08:20

Veterans continue to grapple with pension issues

Veterans continue to grapple with pension issues
PUNE: Defence minister Manohar Parrikar's latest assurance of resolving issues related to revised pension according to the One Rank One Pension (OROP) scheme within two months seems to have hardly reassured the ex-servicemen in the city.
Leave aside OROP, effective from July 1, 2014, many of these ex-servicemen find themselves trapped in the bureaucratic rigmarole of establishing their credentials such as qualifying service and rank weightage to be eligible to get even the pension last revised on January 1, 2006. They continue to get a pension effective before 2006.
Captain Shreepad N Dongre, who retired from Indian Army in 1987 after 25 years of service, said, "I am getting a basic pension of Rs13,850 per month plus a dearness allowance (DA) at 125% of basic pension. I should have been getting Rs16,145 basic pension from January 2006 and Rs17,010 from July 2014 as per OROP."
Dongre has been struggling with the authorities for quite some time for finalization and actual disbursal of the revised pension with arrears. "After repeated follow-ups, they have now fixed my revised pension at Rs15,350 from January 2006 and Rs15,945 from July 2014 but they are not correct considering my service and rank weightage. I am still to get even this wrongly revised pension as the Centralized Pension Processing Centre (CPPC) of the State Bank of India, where I hold my pension account, had no details of my qualifying service," he told TOI.
According to Commander (Retired) Ravi Pathak, "OROP is just one part of the issue. We hope it will get resolved soon, now that the Justice L Narasimha Reddy Commission, which looked into the anomalies arising out of OROP implementation, has submitted its report to the government. We would have preferred the government to make the report public.
"The larger issue though, is of the need to take a serious relook into the pension fixation and disbursal system — right from the service headquarters to the defence accounts office and the banks — to make it more efficient and friendly to ex-servicemen pensioners," said Pathak, associated with the Indian Ex-servicemen Movement, a body of individual veterans of the Indian armed forces.
"Inordinate delay in the issuance of Pension Pay Orders (PPOs), errors in them, PPOs and circulars not reaching pensioners in remote and rural areas, absence of computerized database (related to retirees) with the defence accounts and the banks, bureaucratic approach and lack of response to grievances raised by pensioners are just some of the many problems to point out," he said.
Air Force Association (AFA)-Maharashtra's Group Captain (Retired) Suhas Pathak, who has worked extensively in the area of resolution of pension matters of ex-servicemen, said, "I have handled 97,447 cases over the past 10 years, including 16,334 matters involving widows of ex-servicemen. Twice, we have given written representations to the Chief of Army Staff, Controller-General of Defence Accounts and other authorities."
The AFA-Maharashtra is an officially recognized body which scrutinizes complaints form ex-servicemen related to their pension dues and coordinates with the defence accounts, banks, service headquarters authorities and the directorate of air veterans to get these matters resolved, said Group Captain (Retired) Suhas Kelkar.
Usually, the bank finalizes the revised pension amount on the basis of the pension parameters of the ex-serviceman concerned such as qualifying service (actual time served in uniform) and rank weightage, meant for counting a notional service term towards early retirement from armed forces, date of birth and retirement, and type of pension.
These parameters are specified in the PPO issued to the bank by the Principal Controller of Defence Accounts-Pension (PCDA-P). In case of missing details, the bank seeks clarification from the PCDA-P or the latter conveys the same to the bank in cases where the ex-serviceman raises a grievance.
According to Pathak, "Till 2006, the banks would simply go by the authorized pension shown in the PPO. They would calculate the DA applicable on the same and disburse the revised pension to the ex-servicemen concerned. The PCDA-P stopped issuing PPOs for pre-2006 retirees and instead started issuing tables of revised pension for different ranks, for the banks to make calculations for themselves.
"That is where problems started to arise as the banks do not have sufficient database of the retirees and their pension parameters. The staff is not sufficiently trained and qualified to deal with pension matters and there is over-reliance on bureaucratic procedures like not processing a matter till the bank gets a physical copy of any circular related to pension or response to its queries raised with PCDA-P," he said.
"The PCDA-P has not completed digitization of records despite having started the process in 1986. It continues to rely on the old brown-paper, at times moth-eaten, documents whenever there is a query from bank or a grievance from ex-serviceman. After a lot of hue and cry, it has now started issuing PPOs for pre-2006 retirees, but the same contains errors like showing a reduced rank, wife's name changed, date of birth changed or the PPO, after issuance, going to the wrong authority. And then, the PCDA-P authorities do not respond to queries. Even the banks complain about this."
All these issues result in a lot of time-consuming procedure and cause undue anxiety and concern to the ex-servicemen.
Source:TOI


Thursday, 27 October 2016

08:11

Justice Reddy committee on OROP submits report

Justice Reddy committee on OROP submits report 

The one-man judicial committee on One Rank One Pension (OROP) submitted its report to the Defence Minister Shri Manohar Parrikar, here today. The Central Government had appointed the committee under the Chairmanship of Justice L Narasimha Reddy, retired Chief Justice of Patna High Court to look into the anomalies, if any, arising out of implementation of OROP.

The judicial committee had held hearings at around 20 cities/towns across the country and interacted with cross sections of Ex-Servicemen as well as their associations. The committee also received 704 representations from individuals and various Ex-Servicemen associations and had held extensive interactions with all stakeholders before submitting its report.

Source:PIBNEWS

Friday, 5 February 2016

15:38

Government issue One Rank One Pension tables and implementation instructions

Government issue One Rank One Pension tables and implementation instructions

The Government of India had taken the historic decision to implement OROP in November, 2015. This fulfilled the long standing demand of the Defence Forces personnel after 42 years and benefited over 18 lakh ex-servicemen and war widows.

In pursuance of the order issued on 07/11/2015, detailed instructions alongwith OROP Tables have been issued today.

The annual recurring financial implication on account of implementation of OROP at the current rate will be approximately Rs. 7500 crore.

The arrears from 01/07/2014 to 31/12/2015 would be approximately Rs. 10,900 crore.

86 percent of the total expenditure on account of OROP will benefit the JCOs/ORs.

Payment of arrears and revision of pension under OROP is to be made by the Pension Disbursing Authorities in four installments, except for family pensioners and pensioners in receipt of gallantry awards who will be paidarrears in one installment.

The total increase in the Defence Budget for pensions is estimated to go up from Rs. 54,000 crore (BE 2015-16) to around Rs. 65,000 crore (proposed BE 2016-17), thereby increasing the Defence Pension Outlay by about 20 percent.

Read the DESW Order No.12(1)/2014/D(Pen/Pol)-Part-II dated 03.02.2016 on One Rank One Pension(OROP) to the Defence Forces Personnel below :

No.12(1)/2014/D(Pen/Policy)-Part-II
Government of India
Ministry of Defence
Department of Ex-Servicemen Welfare

New Delhi, Dated: 03 February, 2016

To
The Chief of Army Staff
The Chief of Navy Staff
The Chief of Air Staff

Subject: One Rank One Pension to the Defence Forces personnel.

Sir,

The undersigned is directed to refer this Ministry’s letter No 12(1)/2014/D(Pen/Policy)-Part-II dated 7th November, 2015 notifying One Rank One Pension (OROP) scheme for Defence Forces personnel. Salient features of the scheme have been mentioned at Para 3 & 4 of above said letter with the provision that the benefit of the scheme shall be implemented from 1.7.2014 to all pre-1.7.2014 pensioners. Para 6 of the letter provides that detailed instructions relating to implementation of OROP along with tables indicating revised pension for each rank and each category, shall be issued separately for updation of pension and payment ofarrears by Pension Disbursing Agencies concerned.

2.The undersigned is directed to say that in order to quicken the process of revision of pension/family pension, total 101 pension tables indicating rates of pension/family pension under OROP scheme notified vide this Ministry’s order dated 7th Nov, 2015, are appended to this order. The appended tables indicate revised rates of Retiring/Service/ Special/ Disability/ Invalid/ Liberalized disability/War Injury Pension including disability/war injury element and ordinary/ special/ liberalized family pension of Commissioned Officers, Honorary Commissioned Officers, JCOs/ORs and Non-Combatants (Enrolled) of Army, Navy, Air Force, Defence Security Corps & Territorial Army retired/discharged/invalided out from service/died in service or after retirement. The existing pension of all pre-1.7.2014 pensioners/family pensioners shall be enhanced with reference to applicable table for the rank (and group in case of JCOs/ORs) in which pension with reference to the actual qualifying service as shown in Column-I of the tables subject to maximum term of engagement for each rank as applicable from time to time. The rate of pension of pensioners/ family pensioners drawing pension more than the rate of revised pension/ family pension indicated in annexedtables, shall remain unchanged.

3. The undersigned is also directed to convey that full pension of PSU absorbees who had opted for 100% commutation of pension, shall also be revised under this order with reference to revised pension of the rank determined for regular category of pensioners. However, there shall be no change in restored amount of pension already notified by respective PSAs in their case.

APPLICABILITY

4. The provisions of this letter shall be applicable to all pensioners/family pensioners who had been retired/discharged/ invalided out from service/died in service or after retirement in the rank of Commissioned Officers, honorary commissioned officers, JCOs/ORs and Non-Combatants (Enrolled) of Army, Navy, Air Force, Defence Security Corps, Territorial Army & Ex-State Forces and are in receipt of pension/ family pension as on 1.7.2014.

4.1 The provisions of this order, however, do not apply to UK/HKSRA/KCIO pensioners, Pakistan & Burma Army pensioners, Reservist pensioners and pensioners in receipt of Ex-gratia payments.

METHODOLOGY FOR IMPLEMENTATION

5. All Pension Disbursing Agencies (PDAs) handling disbursement of pension to Defence pensioners are hereby authorized to carry out revision of Retiring/Service/ Special/Disability/Invalid/Liberalized disability/War Injury Pension including disability/war injury element and ordinary/special/liberalized family pension of all pre- 1.7.2014 pensioners drawing pension as on 1.7.2014 in terms of these orders with applicable rates of dearness relief without calling for any applications from the pensioners and without any further authorization from the Pension Sanctioning Authorities concerned.

6. Where the revised pension as on 1.7.2014 worked out in terms of these orders, happens to be less than the existing pension/ family pension as on 1.7.2014, the pension shall not be revised to the disadvantage of the pensioner.

7. Arrears on account of revision of pension from 1.7.2014 till date of its implementation shall be paid by the Pension Disbursing Agencies in four equal half yearly installments. However, all the family pensioners including those in receipt of Special/Liberalized family pension and all Gallantry award winners shall be paidarrears in one installment.

8. The initial Pension Payment Order (PPO) or its Corrigendum PPO (Corr PPO) indicates rank,group and qualifying service for which the individual has been pensioned. This information is available with Pension Disbursing Agencies as they have revised pension of all such pensioners in the recent past in terms of Government orders issued for implementation of recommendations of Sixth CPC, CSC-2009 & CSC-2012. In case, however, any information regarding qualifying service, rank, group etc., is not available with Pension Disbursing Agencies, such cases may be referred to Pension Sanctioning Authority concerned on the proforma enclosed as Annexure-A. The Pension Sanctioning Authorities concerned will provide the requisite information from the available records within 15 days of the receipt of request from the Pension Disbursing Agencies.

9. In case of any doubt relating to revision of pension in terms of this order, pension disbursing agencies may immediately take up the matter with nodal officers of respective PSAs details of which shall be notified by Pr.CDA(P) Allahabad in their implementation instructions.

10. The OROP shall be basic pension from 1.7.2014 and therefore, additional pension as applicable to the old age pensioners/ family pensioners on attaining the relevant age (80 years and above) shall also be enhanced by the PDAs from 1.7.2014 or the date from which the pensioner attains the age of 80 years or more, whichever is later.

PAYMENT OF LIFE TIME ARREARS (LTA)

11. If a pensioner to whom the benefit accrues under the provisions of this letter has died/dies before receiving the payment of arrears, the Life Time Arrears of pension (LT A) shall be paid in the following manner: –

a) If the claimant is already in receipt of Family Pension or happens to be the person in whose favour Family Pension already stands notified and the awardees has not become ineligible for any reason, the LTA under the provisions of this letter should be paid to such a claimant by the PDA on their own.
b) If the claimant has already received LTA in the past in respect of the deceased to whom the benefit would have accrued, the LTA under the provisions of this letter should also be paid to such a claimant by the PDA on their own.
c) If the claimant is a person other than the one mentioned at 11(a) & 11(b) above, payment of LTA shall be made to the legal heir/heirs as per extant Government orders.

12. The following elements shall continue to be paid as separate elements in addition to the pension revised under these orders-
i) Monetary allowance attached to gallantry awards viz. Param Vir Chakra, Ashok Chakra etc.
ii) Constant Attendance Allowance, where admissible.
iii) Dearness relief as sanctioned by the Government from time to time.

MISCELLANEOUS INSTRUCTIONS

13. No arrears on account of revision of pension/family pension shall be admissible for the period prior to 1.7.2014.

14. No commutation of pension shall be admissible on revised/additional amount of pension accruing as a result of revision of pension under these orders. However, the existing amount of pension, if any, that has been commuted will continue to be deducted from the revised pension.

15. As a result of these orders, there will be no change in the amount of gratuity already determined and paid with reference to the rules in force at the time of discharge/invalidment/ death.

16. Any overpayment of pension coming to the notice or under process of recovery shall be adjusted in full by the Pension Disbursing Agencies against arrears becoming due on revision of pension on the basis of these orders.

METHODOLOGY FOR REPORTING

17. An intimation regarding disbursement of revised pension shall be furnished by the Pension Disbursing Agencies to the Office of the Pr. CDA(P) Allahabad in the format prescribed as Annexure¬B to this letter in the following month in which revision takes place. PDAs shall also ensure that an intimation regarding revision of pension is invariably conveyed to the pensioners concerned for their information irrespective of the fact the same is beneficial to them or not. The Public Sector Banks who are disbursing defence pension through Central Pension Processing Centres (CPPC), the progress report shall be furnished by the CPPC of the bank directly to the office of the PCDA (Pensions) Allahabad through electronic scrolls.

18. All other terms and conditions which are not affected by this order shall remain unchanged.

19. This issues with concurrence of Finance Division of this Ministry vide their ID No PC. 1 to 10(11)/2012/FIN/PEN dated 2.2.2016 .

(Manoj Sinha)
Under Secretary to the Govt. of India

Source:GovEmployees

Sunday, 8 November 2015

06:50

ONE RANK ONE PENSION IMPLEMENTATION NOTIFICATION

ONE RANK ONE PENSION IMPLEMENTATION NOTIFICATION

Notification for Implementation of OROP Issued

The Government today issued the notification regarding  implementation of ‘One Rank One Pension’ in respect of Defence Forces  personnel.

Defence Forces of India have a rich history and tradition of bravery and gallantry. Defence forces have not only defend our borders with exemplary courage and valour but have also performed with fearless attitude and empathy in natural calamities and other trying circumstances. Government of India recognizes and respects their contribution.

The issue of One Rank One Pension was a long standing   demand. Defence Forces had been demanding it for almost four decades but the issue could not be resolved. However, Prime Minister Shri Narendra Modi had made a commitment to implement it for the welfare of the ex-servicemen. Accordingly the Government had announced modalities for implementation of OROP on 05.09.2015.  The Government Order by Ministry of Defence, which could not be issued due to model code of conduct, has been issued today.

Salient features of the OROP as stated in the Order are as follows: 

I.To begin with, pension of the past pensioners would be re-fixed on the basis of pension of retirees of calendar year 2013 and the benefit will be effective with effect from 1.7.2014. 

II.Pension will be re-fixed for all pensioners on the basis of the average of minimum and maximum pension of personnel retiring in 2013 in the same rank and with the same length of service. 

III.Pension for those drawing above the average shall be protected. 

IV.Arrears will be paid in four equal half yearly instalments. However, all the family pensioners, including those in receipt of Special/Liberalized family pensioners, and Gallantry award winners shall be paid arrears in one instalment.

V.In future, the pension would be re-fixed every 5 years. 

4. Personnel who opt to get discharged henceforth on their  own request under Rule 13(3)1(i)(b),13(3)1(iv) or Rule 16B of the Army Rule 1954 or equivalent Navy or Air Force Rules will not be entitled to the benefits of OROP. It will be effective prospectively.

5. The Govt. has decided to appoint a Judicial Committee to look into anomalies, if any, arising out of implementation of OROP. The Judicial Committee will submit its report in six months.  

6. Detailed instructions along with tables indicating revised pension for each rank and each category, shall be issued separately for updation of pension and payment of arrears directly by Pension Disbursing Agencies.  

The previous Government had made a budget announcement to implement the OROP and made a provision of Rs 500  Crore. The present Government undertook the task earnestly and realized that the actual additional annual expenditure would be eight to ten thousand crore at present and will increase further in future.Notwithstanding the financial constraints, true to its commitment the present Government has issued the Government order to implement the OROP in true spirit.

Source :PIBNEWS


                                                  

Tuesday, 20 October 2015

21:08

One Rank One Pension, Pay Commission will not impact fiscal deficit: Jayant Sinha

One Rank One Pension, Pay Commission will not impact fiscal deficit: Jayant Sinha 

NEW DELHI: Implementation of One Rank One Pension (OROP) and increase in salary bill due to 7th Pay Commission will not strain government's fiscal position, Minister of State for Finance Jayant Sinha today said. 

"I think we are in a very good shape as far as fiscal management is concerned. That was appreciated by all economists," he said while interacting with reporters after a meeting of economists which was chaired by Finance Minister Arun Jaitley at NITI Aayog. 

He made it clear that the government's fiscal position is strong enough to bear the impact of OROP and implementation of 7th Pay Commission. 

OROP is likely to result in an outgo of Rs 8,000-10,000 crore this fiscal. The 7th Pay Commission report in December is expected to recommend a hike in salary of central government employees. 

The pre-Budget meeting discussed various issues, including agriculture productivity, job creation and fiscal expenditure. 

"We had some of India's most eminent economists and commentators there. Obviously, it is very early in the cycle to start the consultation. But we felt that if there were good ideas, we could incorporate them even in this fiscal year. Obviously, for the preparation of the current budget, we could begin the work on that right now," he said.

"It was very good interaction and we look forward to incorporating much of this for this fiscal year as well as coming fiscal." 

There were several topics that came up, Sinha said, adding that "one very important topic that we spent time on is agriculture and what we could do to increase productivity in agriculture". 

The meeting also dwelt at length on fiscal expenditure and how to ensure fiscal expenditure, particularly public investment, could be as productive as possible. 

"Third major area that we spoke about is obviously the financial sector... more credit for agriculture, MSMEs and what could we do further to strengthen our banks. The final area that we also spent time on is how to ensure we are able to create more jobs for young people, whether it is in the manufacturing sector or the service sector," he said. 

NITI Aayog Vice-Chairman Arvind Panagariya, Chief Economic Adviser Arvind Subramanian and Reserve Bank Deputy Governor Urjit Patel were present. 

Besides, the meeting was attended by Finance Secretary Ratan P Watal, Economic Affairs Secretary Shaktikanta Das, Revenue Secretary Hasmukh Adhia and Financial Services Secretary Anjuly Chib Duggal. 

Economists such as Subir Gokarn, Director of Research at the Brookings Institution India, Ajit Ranade, Chief Economist, Aditya Birla Group, and Rajiv Lall, Vice-Chairman IDFC Ltd, also participated. 


Sunday, 6 September 2015

19:39

The Prime Minister travelled from Central Delhi to Faridabad,PM inaugurates Badarpur-Faridabad Metro Line

PM inaugurates Badarpur-Faridabad Metro Line

The Prime Minister, Shri Narendra Modi, today declared that the respect for armed forces veterans and those who laid down their lives for the nation is paramount for the country. Recalling his promise of delivering One-Rank, One-Pension for the armed forces personnel, the Prime Minister said the Union Government had fulfilled this promise, with the announcement made yesterday. He said that the cost of implementing this promise would be around Rs. 8000 crore to Rs. 10,000 crore, which was significantly higher than some estimates that had been made earlier. The Prime Minister was speaking after inaugurating the Badarpur-Faridabad Metro Line at Faridabad. 

The Prime Minister regretted that it had become a fashion to politicize every decision taken by the Union Government for the progress of the country. Asserting that no one should mislead the jawans and the people of the nation, the Prime Minister said that the country would progress not through Raj-neeti (politics), but through Rashtra-neeti (nationalist policies). 

The Prime Minister said that a significant proportion of army jawans were from Haryana, and therefore, the announcement of OROP would contribute significantly to Haryana's economy. 

Reiterating that development is the solution to all problems, the Prime Minister said the Union Government is taking all steps for India's development. He said the whole world had recently faced economic difficulties, but India's economy had stood firm. He added that all State Governments and the Union Government had to move forward shoulder to shoulder. He reiterated his Government's resolve for Housing for All by 2022. 

The Prime Minister travelled from Central Delhi to Faridabad, and back, by metro. In the course of the journey, he interacted with several people, especially youth, who were also travelling on board the metro train. 
16:53

Premature Retirement benefit from OROP - Prime Minister Narendra Modi

Premature Retirement benefit from OROP - Prime Minister Narendra Modi 

Prime Minister Narendra Modi said on Sunday that military personnel who retired prematurely will benefit from one rank one pension (OROP), reaching out to veterans a day after his government announced the scheme but differences emerged over entitlements to those who opt for voluntary retirement.

"VRS (voluntary retirement scheme) key naam pe bhram failaya jaa raha hai (Some people are trying to spread confusion in the name of VRS)," Modi said at a rally in Faridabad, stressing his respect for the armed forces.

Modi’s olive branch, however, did not appear to deter veterans who want equal facilities for those who opt for VRS.

"Agitation will continue, and it will intensify further," Maj Gen (retired) Satbir Singh said in response to the Prime Minister’s announcement at a protest in Jantar Mantar. TV reports said veterans want a written assurance from the government on contentious points regarding OROP.

Though the Centre announced on Saturday that the OROP scheme will be implemented from July 1, 2014 – with arrears amounting to anywhere between Rs 10,000 crore and Rs 12,000 crore – confusion persisted on certain key issues. 

While announcing the scheme, defence minister Manohar Parrikar said pensions will be re-calculated every five years but military personnel who took “voluntary retirement” will not be entitled to OROP.

The veterans, who have been holding protests across the country for more than two months, want the pension to be reviewed every two years and the benefits of the scheme extended even to those who retire voluntarily or prematurely from the armed forces.

Another bone of contention is the government's decision to set up a single-member judicial committee to look into different aspects of OROP, including inter-services matters. The government said the panel will submit its report in six months but veterans want a deadline of 30 days. They also demanded that the panel have five members, including three veterans.

With the ex-servicemen showing no signs of budging, Modi said his government had delivered on the OROP promise, even though the scheme was stuck for more than four decades and previous regimes had failed to make any breakthrough.

Modi was speaking after he inaugurated an extension of a Delhi Metro line that will benefit nearly 200,000 commuters a day.

"Jinhone khud ney kaam nahi kiya, unhe haq hai kya bolney ka? (The people who have not worked don't have the right to say something in this regard)," Modi said, in a veiled dig at the opposition Congress, which accused the government of diluting several provisions related to OROP.

The scheme, expected to benefit three million pensioners, will guarantee equal pension to military personnel retiring in the same rank with the same length of service, regardless of the date of retirement.

Source :http://www.hindustantimes.com/india-news/soldiers-who-retired-prematurely-will-get-orop-benefits-modi/article1-1387958.aspx

Saturday, 5 September 2015

16:53

You're out of options, General Satbir Singh: Take the OROP now and head for the courts

You're out of options, General Satbir Singh: Take the OROP now and head for the courts

The government is set to announce its One Rank One Pension (OROP) proposal at 3 pm. And from all accounts, the ex-servicemen are set to reject it.

There is a thing called principle, and it is alive and potent, and it fights and flies in the face of pragmatism.

It is also hard to hang in there when the ground support is melting away like lava.

The ex-servicemen will be confronted with just this pressure if they insist on continuing with their demands after Saturday. You don’t have to like it, but when it comes to games of political chess, the bureaucratic babus of India are grandmasters at the board and these soldiers are no match for them.

The announcement by the government of the sanction of the OROP should have been greeted with whoops of joy. Instead, there is a sense of betrayal because the annual pension review is not integrated in the decision, and the government has chosen the clever path of giving in unilaterally but not totally.

Argument: the concession has not been brought about through mutual negotiations and the petitioners have not been party to the contents of the final document.

The general sentiment is that there is no honour in such a conclusion. The former soldiers feel like prisoners of war who are not party to their release and what it entails. They have just been told the war is over, they can go.

Two ways of looking at this situation.

One: The review could have been added in the announcement and then acted upon each year as per the socio-economic conditions prevalent in the country at that juncture. Once the protest had disbanded, it would have become impossible to bring the steam back into the cooker and the ex-servicemen would just have had to accept the situation from year to year.
In the long term, it may have been the better choice for the government.

Two: The government doesn’t like to be strong-armed into surrender, however legitimate the demands. If it is seen to capitulate, others will leap onto the bandwagon.
So it has chosen the half-and-half option and predicated it to a scenario in which the nation per se gets a bit fed up with the whole thing, and begins to believe the former soldiers have pushed their luck.

It’s a pretty simple equation.

Prime Minister Narendra Modi has kept his word. They wanted OROP, they got what they wanted, now back off. Spin doctors will catapult this imagery across the nation and are probably already hard at work to dispense this pearl of wisdom.

I am afraid that the agitation may continue and it is perhaps exactly what the government hopes for. With every extra day of protest at Jantar Mantar, the ex-servicemen begin to look that much more ungrateful. 

To the average mind, you have eaten the grass, Sir, what are you hanging around for?

So the question is that if they reject it as an association, are they speaking for thousands of other soldiers and officers who want this financial relief and are probably saying , hey there, let it go, we have fought and won the high ground? More vitally, can the government implement OROP despite the rejection by the protestors? Yes, it can. That way the General Satbir Singh-led regiment literally gets isolated and that seems to be the aim. Reduce the agitation to a mere handful of old men making strident sounds and get on with governance.

“After all, people of India, we kept our pledge, honoured the 15 August made by the Prime Minister to our brave soldiers, now we cannot keep responding to other demands. Come on, chaps, be happy.”

It will be very easily forgotten that the annual review (or even a bi-annual) was integral to the OROP movement.

So, if we concede that the government has won by ‘losing’ and given the OROP mandate with a five-year review element, all of which has the Ex-Servicemen’s League teed off, what now?

You are General Singh.  What are your options?
You can continue to sit at Jantar Mantar until your own cadres start wondering if it is worth it. How long can you keep going? Even worthy causes run out of stamina.

You can accept it all gracefully now while putting on record your disagreements, and then go legal for the annual pension review using the precedents that exist for it as your platform. Fight for it in the courts.

That is smart and logical and gets you to leave that Jantar Mantar stage with grace and dignity intact. And the OROP in your pocket.

And your principles.

Source :First Post



From Hindustan Times..

Govt announces OROP, veterans say agitation will continue

The Narendra Modi government on Saturday announced the much-waited OROP scheme for defence veterans, but the ex-servicemen 'categorically' rejected all the proposals and said they will continue to protest.

Defence minister Manohar Parrikar announced the one rank, one pension scheme during a press conference assuring an equal pension to three million military personnel retiring in the same rank with the same length of service, regardless of the date of retirement.

"The government has accepted OROP in true spirit without being constrained by previous inaccurate estimates. Despite the huge financial burden, the government has taken the decision to implement OROP. The previous government had estimated a cost of Rs 500 crore, however, the reality is that OROP would cost Rs. 8000 crore to the exchequer to implement and it will keep increasing," Parrikar told reporters in New Delhi.

The minister said the arrears would amount to anywhere between Rs 10,000 crore and Rs 12,000 crore.

"OROP review will occur every five years and the scheme will be effective from July 1, 2014, and the base year would be 2013," he added.

Parrikar said the government would constitute a single-member judicial committee to look into various aspects of OROP, including inter-services matters, and it will submit its report in six months.

OROP arrears will be paid in four half-yearly installments and all widows, including war widows, will get arrears in lump-sum. Army personnel who have taken voluntary retirement will not be covered under OROP.

He said an order on OROP will be issued by the ministry of defence very soon.

"PM Modi has fulfilled his commitment and implement OROP. I appeal to the veterans now to continue the task of nation building," he said.

Agitating ex-servicemen, who had met Parrikar earlier in the day, rejected the government's announcements saying they are not fully satisfied.

"We only accept one point made by the government and that is the implementation of OROP and categorically reject everything else," said Major General Satbir Singh (retd), who heads the Indian Ex-Servicemen Movement.

He said they cannot accept the government's proposal on one-man judicial panel that will offer its report in six months saying the time period has to be thirty days and demanded for a five-member panel of which three should be veterans, one serving serviceman and an officer of their choice.

The veterans, who had been holding protests across the country for 82 days, also rejected the government's proposal of a five-year review period of pensions saying they must be reviewed every year.

"A senior officer can never receive a smaller pension than a junior officer," said Maj Gen Singh.

He said they need more clarification on whether premature retirement qualifies for the scheme, issue of averaging of pension and the government's decision to not give OROP benefits to those who have opted for voluntary retirement scheme (VRS).

"At least 40% of our servicemen take VRS and if the government still doesn't accept it then it is a big blow to the forces."

Maj Gen Singh said they will take a call on the hunger strike and inform the media later in the evening.

"For now, the consensus we have arrived at is that the OROP agitation will continue," he said.

16:17

Government announces OROP, pension of ex-servicemen will be revised every 5 years

Government announces OROP, pension of ex-servicemen will be revised every 5 years

OROP arrears to be paid in four half-yearly instalments; all widows, including war widows, to be paid arrears in one instalment.

Despite huge financial burden, the government has taken a decision to implement the One Rank One Pension, Defence Minister Manohar Parrikar announced on Saturday.

Benefit of OROP will be given with effect from July 1, 2014, a date immediately after the present government assumed office, Mr. Parrikar said.

OROP arrears to be paid in four half-yearly instalments; all widows, including war widows, to be paid arrears in one instalment.

To begin with, OROP would be fixed on the basis of calendar year 2013, he said. Pension will be re-fixed for all pensioners retiring in the same rank and same length of service.

The government is considering appointing a committee under a judge to go into the issue of equalisation of pension, a leader of the ex-servicemen group fighting for One Rank One Pension said after a meeting with Defence Minister Manohar Parrikar.

Veterans react

It is good what govt has announced on OROP, we are satisfied, Major Gen (Retd) Satbir Singh said after Mr. Parrikar made an onnuncement on OROP.

"We do not accept the decision not to give OROP benefits to those who have taken voluntary retirement," Mr. Singh said.

Ex-servicemen however, disapproved of setting up of one-member judicial committee. "It should be under Defence minister and not given more than one month," Mr. Singh said.

They have sought clarifications on issues like pre-mature retirement benefits and averaging of pension. According to us, govt has only accepted one of our demands and rejected six, Mr. Singh said.

Pension equalisation, an issue

Maj Gen Satbir Singh (Retd), Chairman of Indian Ex-Servicemen said the government while accepting the concept of the OROP, was still insisting on pension revision every five years and that is why it was thinking of constituting a committee.

Mr. Singh said after the meeting that in that case a representative of the veterans and one from the services should also be in the committee. He said the committee should not take more than one month.

Ahead of government’s likely announcement of OROP, Mr. Singh said government has broadly accepted the concept of the scheme and that they will study the details after it is made public.

The delegation, he said, presented their views on the sticky issues including pension equalisation.

“Government has accepted the OROP concept broadly,” the Chairman of Indian Ex-Servicemen movement told reporters after the meeting.

'No junior should get more pension than senior'

He said it was conveyed to the Defence Minister that no junior should get more pension than senior and that there is nothing like Voluntary Retirement Service in defence forces.

Sounding a conciliatory note, Mr. Singh said the government has accepted 60 per cent of the demands of the ex—servicemen.

He, however, said the “bone of contention” — revision of pension — still remains.

Parrikar meets Amit Shah

After the meeting Mr. Parrikar met BJP president Amit Shah.

Later a BJP leader said all demands of the ex-servicemen have been accepted except the pension revision demand.

BJP MP Meenakshi Lekhi, who was present at the party chief’s house, said government is close to announcing a solution that will cost the exchequer at least Rs 10,000 crore.

The ex-servicemen have been demanding that the pension revision should take place at least in every two years while government has proposed a five-year revision.

All about OROP:

1 Defence Minister Manohar Parrikar announced thedecision to implement the One Rank One Pension, w.e.f July 1, 2014.

2 OROP arrears to be paid in four half-yearly instalments; all widows, including war widows, to be paid arrears in one instalment.

3 The ex-servicemen, who have been agitating for the last 82 days, said they will not accept review of the pension after every five years.

4 It is understood that a draft proposal on OROP was circulated at a RSS meeting on Friday, which envisaged commencement of the scheme from July 2014, besides revision of pension every five years.

5 Veterans have opposed to excluding ex-servicemen, who had opted for pre-mature retirement, from the ambit of OROP.

6 Defence Minister Manohar Parrikar announced the setting up of a One member Judicial Committee, which will give its report on OROP in six months.

7 Veterans have rejected this committee, and instead demanded a committee under the Defence Minister which will include an ex-serviceman too.

8 To begin with, OROP would be fixed on the basis of calender year 2013.

9 Officials said the annual burden on the pension bill will be about Rs. 8,000 crore which would progressively go up with revision in pensions. The current pension bill of the defence ministry stands at Rs. 54,000 crore.

10 Close to 22 lakh retired servicemen and over six lakh war widows stand to be the immediate beneficiaries of the scheme.

Source :The Hindu
13:58

ANNOUNCEMENT OF 'ONE RANK ONE PENSION' BY GOVERNMENT TODAY

ANNOUNCEMENT OF  'ONE RANK ONE PENSION' BY GOVERNMENT LIKELY TO TODAY

NEW DELHI: An announcement about 'One Rank One Pension' is expected to be made today by the government notwithstanding key differences with ex-servicemen, who have made it clear that any unilateral decision would not be accepted.

The possibility of an announcement was being talked about in official circles, although ex-servicemen maintained that there was no agreement on revision of pension. The ex-servicemen have indicated that they may accept a revision every two years but the government has been insisting that equalization will happen once in five years.

The ex-servicemen, who have been agitating for the last 82 days, said they will not accept review of the pension after every five years. It is understood that a draft proposal on OROP was circulated at a RSS meeting yesterday which envisaged commencement of the scheme from July 2014, besides revision of pension every five years.

According to the draft, the basis for the implementation of the scheme would be 2013 and arrears would be paid in four installments.

Reacting to the proposal, the ex-servicemen had threatened to intensify their stir if the government makes any unilateral announcement regarding implementation of OROP which is not in consonance with the terms and conditions set by the defence veterans.

"There are reports that the government may soon unilaterally declare the implementation of OROP. If it is as per our terms and conditions then we will welcome it and thank the government.

"If not, then the unilateral declaration is unacceptable to us. We will intensify our protests," Maj Gen Satbir Singh (retd), Chairman of Indian Ex-Servicemen movement had said.

Singh said the OROP should be implemented from March 31, 2014 and they will not accept if it is done from July, 2014. He claimed the government has to only spend Rs 30 crore for six-consecutive years for "equalisation of pension".

"If the government can spend Rs 60 crore on giving subsidy to Parliament canteen, then I have nothing to say," he said.

The OROP has been stuck for a while despite hectic back channel talks between the government and the veterans.

Source :http://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/defence/government-likely-to-announce-one-rank-one-pension-today/articleshow/48833141.cms

07:46

OROP for Ex-servicemen ,scheme is likely to announced in the next 2-3 days.

OROP for Ex-servicemen ,scheme is likely to announce in the next 2-3 days.

Looking to end the logjam on the issue of One Rank One Pension (OROP) for ex-servicemen, the government has prepared a draft on the modalities of implementing the scheme and an announcement is likely in the next 2-3 days. However ex-servicemen termed it “unilateral” and have rejected the draft.

The major sticking point remains the issue of equalisation. The government is firm on the revision every five years in view of the administrative difficulties of doing it annually, however, the veterans have rejected it. Talks are continuing to find common ground.

“This is the best possible deal we could have worked out considering the financial implications of this in a financial year when recommendations of the 7th Pay Commission will also be submitted. We also feel that a lot of veterans will be satisfied with this deal once it is explained, we hope that the protests end soon," said a senior minister in the government. Earlier this week, the RSS too had raised the matter with the government asking for a speedy resolution within reasonable means. “We have been told by Amit Shah (BJP President) that OROP will be worked out soon,” said RSS joint general secretary Dattatreya Hosabele on the sidelines of the BJP-RSS co-ordination meet in Delhi on Friday.

Speaking at Jantar Mantar, Maj Gen (retd) Satbir Singh, Chairman of Indian Ex-Servicemen Movement (IESM) said they are ready to accept a revision every two years but not beyond that.

Responding on the draft OROP, Wg Cdr (retd) Vinod Nebb with IESM said if the government goes ahead unilaterally, they will continue their agitation. “It is utter rubbish. There is no question of accepting it. In fact we are going to escalate our protests from September 12”.

The veterans have been demanding an annual revision and implementation from April 1, 2014. As per definition OROP seeks uniform pension based on rank and length of service irrespective of when they retire.

The draft says implementation would be from July 1, 2014 as the government was sworn in on May 26, 2014 and 2013 would be the base year for calculation.

In terms of implementation, arrears will be paid immediately for widows while for all others it would be cleared in four instalments over two years.

OROP would be applicable for war widows but those opting for voluntary retirement are not eligible.

Given the complexities in determining duration of service and time of retirement, the government is expected to appoint a judicial commission which will submit a report within six months.

Officials said the annual burden on the pension bill will be about Rs. 8,000 crore which would progressively go up with revision in pensions. The current pension bill of the defence ministry stands at Rs. 54,000 crore.

Source :The Hindu

Friday, 4 September 2015

16:26

OROP @ Government Formula - Central Government

OROP @ Government Formula - Central Government

The government is likely to notify the ‘One Rank, One Pension’ (OROP) scheme, but as per its own definition. This could possibly include a compensation for soldiers retiring before age of 40 and a fixed tenure for revision of pensions to equalise them as per ranks and years of service.

It will take into account the very basic criteria that the pensioners get compensated for having “sticking their neck out” for defending the country and don’t feel let down.

The Bihar Assembly elections are also driving the government to finalise the OROP. Today another meeting was held on the matter to bridge the gaps.

The government formula was listed out by Finance Minister Arun Jaitley two days ago when he laid down a few ground rules for implementing the OROP, a pre-poll promise made down the BJP.

He ruled out any annual pension revision. In the talks between the government and the ex-servicemen, the government had proposed that the hike in pensions — to make them equal for same rank and same length of service — would be done once in five years.

The Indian Ex-Servicemen Movement (IESM) at first agreed for a biennial (once in two years) equalising of pensions, but later withdrew the concession and demanded an annual equalisation. But indications are that a middle path may be worked out on tenure for revision of pensions.

Sources said the Government has made its best offer to the veterans and wants to tread a path that does not open a pandora’s box with similar OROP-type demands from other services like paramilitaries.

The system of equalising the pension is crucial as the OROP entails same pension for all those who retired in the same rank with equal length of service. Ex-servicemen sitting in Dharna have been asking for the OROP without dilution of the recommendations made by the Bhagat Singh Koshyari Committee.

Koshyari, who headed the Rajya Sabha Petitions Committee, said in December 2011: “Uniform pension be paid to armed forces personnel retiring in the same rank with the same length of service, irrespective of their date of retirement, and any future enhancement in the rates of pension be automatically passed on to the old pensioners”.

Source :The Tribune News

Saturday, 15 August 2015

21:23

Indian Railways jumps on OROP bandwagon

Indian Railways jumps on OROP bandwagon

Employees of the Indian Railways have demanded the benefits of the One Rank, One Pension (OROP) policy if the Centre implements the scheme for defence services personnel. They have made this pitch in their discussions with the Seventh Pay Commission.

Speaking to media, Shiva Gopal Mishra, general secretary of the All India Railwaymen’s Federation, the largest railway union in the country, acknowledged the demand. “The principle of OROP should be applicable to the railway employees also if the same is accepted for the defence services by the pay commission. We sympathise with their demand and feel it should be extended,” he said.

The railway unions had met the commission for oral evidence in March this year.

The demand could create complications for the Centre which has so far not been able to respond to the original demand from ex-servicemen. The specific mandate for the pay commission, however, does not include the examination of OROP even though its award will cover military personnel too. The railway employees have, however, made it clear to the commission that if there is any suggestion on OROP in the final report, then their demands should also be considered favourably.

The Commission has already overshot the time frame for submitting its report on a revised salary structure for central government employees, which was due in August. It is now likely to submit the report by September-end.

The demand by railway employees for OROP could lead to demands from other civilian services as well, even as the bill for meeting the demand from the defence services is still being firmed up. At 1.33 million, railway employees form the single largest chunk from among any ministry or department of central government staff. Their salary and allowance bill for 2015-16 is estimated at Rs 62,410 crore, or almost 42 per cent of the total bill of Rs 1,49,524 crore as per budget figures.

While the Seventh Pay Commission, in its internal deliberations, is understood to have not taken a favourable view of the OROP because of the financial implications, any formal examination of the same will have to depend on the government’s position on the issue. The government is now expected to set up a committee on the issue.

Overall, the commission has decided that the extent of rise in pay for all central government staff would, on average, be about 26 per cent. But here too, the commission is learnt to have favoured going back to the Fifth Pay Commission award of making pay scales attached to posts instead of retaining the innovative pay bands system introduced by the Sixth Pay Commission.

It has also decided to remove the slight edge in pay structure of IAS officers as compared to other central service officers.